Search

Super 14

©Touchline

Preview

Preview: Brumbies v Sharks

Thursday, March 11 The Sharks are desperately searching for their first win of the season but the Brumbies will look to make it two-from-two at home when the two teams face off in Canberra on Saturday.

The Sharks produced their best team performance of the season against the Waratahs last week and were denied victory by referee Paul Marks alone. As unacceptable as that may have been, the reality is that the Sharks are still winless after the opening four rounds.

The Brumbies on the other hand have three wins to their name including a comfortable 24-13 win over the Lions in their first home game of the season last week. The win stretched the Brumbies’ incredible home record against South African opposition to 33 victories out of 35 matches.

The Sharks have won only one out of their last eight matches against the Brumbies in Canberra. That lone victory was all the way back in 1998 when they defeated their hosts 41-23. The overall numbers look much more competitive with the Brumbies edging the Durban-based franchise eight wins to seven.

Any way you look at it, however, history and current form favours the Brumbies. But if we have learned anything from this season’s Super 14 to date it is that any side can beat the other on any given day. The Reds have proven it twice with two remarkable upsets of the Crusaders and the Chiefs while the Cheetahs continued the trend by shocking the Hurricanes.

The Sharks have no less than 10 Springboks in their starting line-up as well as England international Andy Goode. For them it is a matter of execution and improving their discipline. Tendai Mtawarira and Bismarck du Plessis return to bolster the front row with captain John Smit reverting to tighthead at the expense of Jannie du Plessis while Jacques Botes replaces Keegan Daniel on the side of the scrum.

The backline remains unchanged with coach John Plumtree giving Ruan Pienaar and Goode another opportunity as the halfback combination.

The Brumbies, with a whopping 12 Wallabies in their starting XV, including an all-Wallaby pack, are a settled unit and have named an unchanged line-up for the third consecutive week.

Key Battle: Matt Giteau v Andy Goode. The Sharks’ latest flyhalf import had a reasonably ‘Goode’ outing last week and will be keen to make a statement against the little Wallaby wizard on Saturday.

Referee: Garratt Williamson

Prediction:
While an upset is not out of the question, the Brumbies ought to bag the four points at home. Brumbies by 7.


Brumbies

13 Mar 10
10:40

Canberra Stadium
Canberra, Australia

Brumbies
 


Ben Alexander 1 Tendai Mtawarira
Stephen Moore 2 Bismarck du Plessis
Salesi Ma'afu 3 John Smit
Ben Hand 4 Steven Sykes
Mark Chisholm 5 Johann Muller
Rocky Elsom 6 Jacques Botes
George Smith 7 Willem Alberts
Stephen Hoiles 8 Ryan Kankowski
Josh Valentine 9 Ruan Pienaar
Matt Giteau 10 Andy Goode
Francis Fainifo 11 JP Pietersen
Christian Lealiifano 12 Riaan Swanepoel
Stirling Mortlock 13 Adrian Jacobs
Pat McCabe 14 Odwa Ndungane
Adam Ashley-Cooper 15 Stefan Terblanche
Huia Edmonds 16 Craig Burden
Guy Shepherdson 17 Jannie Du Plessis
Justin Harrison 18 Alistair Hargreaves
Mitchell Chapman 19 Jean Deysel
Patrick Phibbs 20 Keegan Daniel
Matt Toomua 21 Rory Kockott
Tyrone Smith 22 Waylon Murray
     
  • Captain - Stephen Hoiles
  • Unchanged for third straight week
 
  • Captain - John Smit
  • Botes in for Daniel
  • Bismark and Beast come into the front row with Smit moving to tighthead and Carstens dropping out the 22
  • Burden and Hargreaves included in 22


  • Threshold
  • RSS Feed
  • The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.
By Javelin - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Expect the Sharks to get screwed by an unknown ref - again.

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Sharks will win this game.

By Javelin - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
CSM, I really hope you are right. At least you won last week. I know neither Paul Marks or the scoreboard says so, but you did. We all know you did. Even Lyndon Bray acknowledged as much.

By bluebok - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Everyone has written the Sharks off for this game, a wounded animal is very dangerous when it is backed into a corner. Sharks to surprise us all and take the win away from home.

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Yeah exactly Javelin I feel robbed bout last week but I feel as comfortable as I would have if we won. The Points don't matter that much anymore as I don't think that we are credible title contenders anymore.

Just hope we salvage some pride and get a couple good wins under the belt.

By Gilbert - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
bluebok, this "wounded animal" has been backed into a corner for 4 weeks now...if it was goin to be dangerous it would have done it a while ago. I think a better discription would be a dead animal lying on its back in a corner...with a foul smell coming from it.

By Divan - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
shut up Gilbert! Rather support the Sharks, they're a Saffa team after all! Or dont support any SA team and support an Aussie team.

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Gibert you chop. Jeez bru.. What the hell is wrong with you? You are loving the Sharks' misery aren't you.. Like Divan says go help shag a sheep or something. SA don't need supporters like you.

Even old Javelin is showing some support and we've been at each others throats for long now concerning our beloved teams.

By Javelin - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Come on, Gillie has a point there. He just didn't say it in such a Shark-loving way. We all know the Sharks are better than what their 2010 record suggests, just a matter of time when you will click.

By JDDS69 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
easy win for the brumbies, gits will make goode cry most likely

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Nah he's just being a knob.

By RugbyGal - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I also think the Sharks gonna cause an upset this weekend. Ryan to score 5 tries!

By Gilbert - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Uhm! Wow you guys are seriously uptight aren't you...shame i thought people who lived in Durban we're chilled...

I guess it would be better if i used some lame metaphor from an 80's American Football movie hey CSM?!..but i didn't because i don't think the Sharks are that awesome. SORRY.

As a Lions supporter i have to read about 20 comments like mine a week about how the Lions can't win or have no chance of winning...and most of the time i laugh...cause its all in good spirit. But its cool you and Divan can carry on marshalling the forums and protecting the Sharks from evil people like me...

By JDDS69 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
ha
i like it gilbert

By RugbyGal - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Well Gilbert - I have never seen you say anything positive bout any team but the Bulls and Lions. Come one. Be a South African a bit.

By shacky - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
just because the lions have been losing the last decade,dont come moan here Crying or Very sad

By rickytherocket - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
It all depends which Sharks team pitches up on the day...

At best, I reckon they could pull off an upset. Possibly 5 points in it. At worst, well I'd prefer not to think about what would happen if the wheels fell off again. Could get messy.

By jauk - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Key Battle: Sharks vs Ref

By jauk - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Key Battle: John Smit vs Bismarck du Plessis

By jauk - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
Key Battle: John Plumtree vs Common Sense

By zulustormer - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
if it wasnt for this front row selection i wouldve givin the sharks the benifit of the doubt to beat the pony's. But its the same shyte different day sindrome with this sharks coach.

By pietpompies - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Where the frak is Ludik? Are the Lion's still QQ'ing over his contract?

By SA4life - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Very Happy goodluck to all sa teams and im a stormers fan.

By SA4life - Castle Braai recommendations: 1

By SA4life - Castle Braai recommendations: 1

By SA4life - Castle Braai recommendations: 1

By jauk - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
There are rumours going around that all is not well with the Sharks. Looks like problems between John Smit and the du Plessis brothers. Now here is my 5c - the Dup brothers are old grey boys from the freestate, the same school and place as Ollie le roux. John Smit had much to say about Ollie in his book. Can it be that the Dup brothers are very good friends with Ollie??just a thought.....

By jauk - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I didnt really mean that John Smit must go my friend. I still support john. the bokke made a mistake when they dropped gary teich long ago for skinstad. I believe gary could have won us that world cup. Anyway I respect your idea but dont support it. Wink

By Willeklong - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
The Brumbies proved against the Stormers that they can scrap a game, but the Sharks are way overdue. Difficult one to call. I guess the home side edges it.

By BullsRob - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I'm gonna jump on board with Gille here. Sharks have nobody to blame but themselves. Yes the ref buggered it up but the fact remains if you were any good you would have wrapped things up long before the last 5 mins anyway.

As for "being South African" and supporting the Sharks.... GET BENT! I'd rather speedball my own nuts. Sharks fans can give it but you certainly can't take it. I will shout for every other SA based team (and I do) but the Sharks fans don't deserve my support!

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
@Bullsplank:

Firstly with your logic of if they were any good they would have wrapped up the match long before the 77th minute... Uhm the Bulls won their first super 14 title by scoring in the 83rd minute?? Were the Bulls not good enough? Of course they were, they took the last opportunity. Tha game is 80min long and even after the 80 min the game can be won or lost.

Secondly: "get bent" and "speedball" ??? wtf? Don't want to know what you do in your free time buddy.. We don't want your support.. As far as im concerned any team would be embarrased to have you as a supporter.

By bullinwp - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Laughing Laughing Hier gaan ons alweer....k*k mekaar uit. Ek 'laaik' dit

By mmfa - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Hah, BullsRob, just the wanka type of supporter that keeps me wishing that the Bulls didnt come from SA. I only know one Bulls supporter who supports any other SA team, and thats it - I know plenty others who will support the overseas team against any of our own, so go speedball your own nuts, cos clearly you dont got any ya piece of plankton.

The Sharks could come good tomorrow of they keep disciplined and play like they played at some stages last week. If they keep it together and keep the du plessis boets in line, then maybe we can pull out a victory - its complete crap to say its impossible.

Hey, maybe the Highlanders can land a sucker punch against that group of players of BullsRob. WTF?

By 91,99... - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Too much class Brumbies by 20, Gits has not clicked all year the Canberra boys have points in them now it is time to let it show.

Sharks last week was last week, refs suck the world over, you still could have won if you were good enough to form a simple maul off an attacking line out! You have a team full of stars but cannot stick with key players in key positions for more than one week!

By SharkFin - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
We have this game in the bag... Ruan pull up your sock boytjie!

By BullsRob - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
CSM - The Tahs were knackered after 60 mins. You couldn't convert your pressure into a try. Look, trying to convert me or persuade me to support the Sharks is fools logic. None of you should or would support the Bulls. That's what being a fan is about! Your team above all else.

You ever wonder why it's the Sharks against the rest of SA? Its because you never back up your potential. Yet you shoot your mouths off without fail every year. Yes I'd like to see the Sharks doing better (its worrying you're so shyte with so many Boks) but you're not. I'm not going to support you nor will I get on the "pro-SA" band wagon because you tell me to.

We shouldn't have won the first Super14 title. you got a raw deal, that said a win is a win. We'll take it. We did take it.

You were much stronger opposition in 2007 than the Tahs were for you this year. You comparison has no merit.


mmfa - You wish the Bulls weren't from SA, well I wish we could push Natal out to sea and let freestate keep all their players. Works both ways. If the Bulls left SA you'd have no trophies and no Springboks...

By no15 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
...grow up dude!

By jakid - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Mmfa.What nonsense.Me,my friends,people at work all support any SA team playing even though we are mostly Bulls supporters.

Bullsrob.Underneath all these provincial colours lies the Green and Gold,so if SA teams are doing well, the Boks do well.Then it doesnt matter if they are from Pretoria or Durbs,Bloemfontein or Cape Town.Just as long as they are not from Joburg ok Very Happy Very Happy

By Darkghana - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Just love the comments every week. If it were down to sense of humour we would've won the Super competition every year....

By Sharkling - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Go Sharks!!!! It can't be worse than the Lions!!!

No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register or login.
Login / Register
 
user poll
Will the Boks win any of their upcoming home games?


Results Votes: 1918
Fat Pig Productions
Designed and Implemented by DigIT Solutions All content supplied by SARugby.com Photographs supplied by Gallo Images/Getty Images. All logos and trademarks are the property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all the rest © 2005 Fat Pig Productions CC
The logos and trademarks used on this site are the property of their respective owners
We are not responsible for comments posted by our users, as they are the property of the poster
Advertise with SARugby.com | Legal Notices

SARugby.com is hosted by Hetzner