Search

Springboks

©Touchline

South Africa

Nine new caps in Bok squad

Saturday, October 31 The Springbok selectors have included nine new caps in the squad of 37 that will tour Europe in November.

The squad also includes five players who have been recalled whilst the balance of 23 players is the bulk of the squad that won the 2009 Vodacom Tri-Nations tournament.

The tour includes Test matches against France, Italy and Ireland as well as two midweek matches, against English Premiership teams Leicester and Saracens.

The newcomers are: Vodacom Western Province centre Juan de Jongh, Sharks lock Alistair Hargreaves, Vodacom Free State Cheetahs eighthman Ashley Johnson, the Vodacom Blue Bulls’ hooker Bandise Maku, scrumhalf Heini Adams, flanker Dewald Potgieter and utility back Francois Hougaard; and the GWK Griquas duo of flank Davon Raubenheimer and fullback Riaan Viljoen.

Those recalled are Vodacom Blue Bulls fullback Zane Kirchner and Vodacom Cheetahs wing Jongi Nokwe, who both played in the third Test against the British & Irish Lions in July but were excluded from the Tri-Nations squad, Vodacom Free State Cheetahs centre Meyer Bosman, who was in the SA XV that faced Namibia in May and last played a Test in 2006, Xerox Lions fullback Earl Rose, who toured Europe in 2008 and also featured in the Namibia match, and Xerox Lions prop Heinke van der Merwe, who played one Test match in 2007.

Vodacom Western Province lock Andries Bekker and Sharks wing JP Pietersen, who were injured during the Vodacom Tri-Nations away leg, both return to the squad. The five players who are not included from the group of 28 that did duty during the Tri-Nations are Vodacom Free State flank Juan Smith, who was not considered due to injury, Jean de Villiers and Frans Steyn, who are playing for clubs in Ireland and France respectively, Vodacom Western Province scrumhalf Ricky Januarie and Sharks lock Johann Muller, who was called to replace the injured Bekker towards the end of the Vodacom Tri-Nations away campaign.

Nineteen of the squad were involved in the Absa Currie Cup final on Saturday.

Commenting on the selection, Springbok coach Peter de Villiers said: “We will go on tour with a strong core of players who have reached great heights this season, but we are under no illusions about the challenges we face.

“We have three tough Test matches – France beat the All Blacks in New Zealand earlier this year and are always tough opponents at home, Italy were competitive away from home against the All Blacks and the Wallabies, whilst Ireland are the reigning Six Nations champions.

“We do, however, have a fairly settled Test team that boasts a significant number of caps and is well experienced with some very cool heads. But, what we have achieved so far will have little bearing and we will be starting from scratch as we try to put the seal on a very successful season.”

De Villiers added that the nine newcomers to the squad had been recognised for their performances during the 2009 Absa Currie Cup.

“All of them put their hands up during the Absa Currie Cup,” he said. “There are others who may consider themselves unlucky not to have made it but it’s an indication of our depth that we were forced to leave some very good players at home.

“We will use this tour to expose the new players to our team dynamic and culture as well as to allow them an opportunity to play at a higher level and perhaps even challenge for a place in the Test 22.”

De Villiers said the five-match tour would also allow him the opportunity to assess various players, particularly at inside centre and fullback in the wake of the departure of Jean de Villiers and Frans Steyn.

“There are a host of players who are capable of challenging for these two positions, but at the same time we will continue to reassess ourselves in all positions to ensure that we are strong in every aspect of the game,” De Villiers said.

The squad of 37 will assemble in Johannesburg on Monday 2 November, with the Springbok team for the midweek matches departing for the UK on Tuesday 3 November. The remaining players – essentially a shadow Test XV – will remain in South Africa and depart for France on Tuesday 10 November.

Springbok touring squad 2009

(Test caps in brackets)

Forwards (20): John Smit (Sharks, captain - 90), Victor Matfield (Blue Bulls, vice-captain - 89), Andries Bekker (Western Province - 18), Bakkies Botha (Blue Bulls - 63), Heinrich Brüssow (Cheetahs - 10), Schalk Burger – Western Province - 53), Bismarck du Plessis (Natal Sharks - 30), Jannie du Plessis (Natal Sharks - 12), Alistair Hargreaves (Natal Sharks - 0), Ashley Johnson (Cheetahs - 0), Ryan Kankowski (Natal Sharks - 10), Bandise Maku (Blue Bulls - 0), Tendai Mtawarira (Natal Sharks - 19), Dewald Potgieter (Blue Bulls - 0), Chiliboy Ralepelle (Blue Bulls - 8), Davon Raubenheimer – Griquas - 0), Danie Rossouw (Blue Bulls - 43), Pierre Spies (Blue Bulls - 28), Gurthrö Steenkamp (Blue Bulls - 22), Heinke van der Merwe (Lions - 1).

Backs (17): Heini Adams – Blue Bulls - 0), Meyer Bosman (Cheetahs - 3), Juan de Jongh (Western Province - 0), Fourie du Preez (Blue Bulls - 52), Jaque Fourie (Lions - 51), Bryan Habana (Blue Bulls - 54), Francois Hougaard (Blue Bulls - 0), Adi Jacobs (Natal Sharks - 28), Zane Kirchner (Blue Bulls - 1), Odwa Ndungane (Natal Sharks - 6), Jongi Nokwe (Cheetahs - 4), Wynand Olivier (Blue Bulls - 24), Ruan Pienaar (Natal Sharks - 35), JP Pietersen (Natal Sharks - 30), Earl Rose (Lions - 0), Morné Steyn (Blue Bulls - 9), Riaan Viljoen – Griquas - 0).

Springbok Tour Fixtures:

Nov 6 vs Leicester at Welford Road @ 19h45 (SA 21h45)
Nov 13 TEST vs France at Municipal Stadium, Toulouse @ 20h45 (SA 21h45)
Nov 17 vs Saracens at Wembley Stadium @ 19h45 (SA 21h45)
Nov 21 TEST vs Italy at Stadio Friuli, Udine @ 15h00 (SA 16h00)
Nov 28 TEST vs Ireland at Croke Park, Dublin @ 14h30 (SA 16h30)


  • Threshold
  • RSS Feed
  • The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.
By forgottenplayer - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Earl Rose and Bandise Maku??? I would have seen Joe Pietersen and Adrian Strauss instead of them. Glad that Ricky can sort out his trouble with the justice system. Great to see HvdM backin the mix. Only five props but six player who can play 8. Naja.

By KaRmA77 - Castle Braai recommendations: 2
Heini Adams Confused

Earl Rose Confused

Bandise Maku Confused

Chilliboy Ralephelle Confused

Davon Raubenheimer Confused

QUOTA QUOTA QUOTA Wink

By KaRmA77 - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
I am happy with the selections of Francois Hougaard, Riaan Viljoen, Alistair Hargreaves, Ashley Johnson and Heinke VanDerMerwe Razz

By jakid - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
Earl Rose?????? Sad Come on!!

By cramer - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
Hardly any of the fringe players that were selected actually starts for their respected unions.

By jakid - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
Cant believe Earl Rose is in again.Who is he sleeping with??

By shacky - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
Stefan Terblance NOT Earl Rose
Derrick Kuun NOT Bandise Maku
Steven Sykes NOT Alistair Hargreaves

BUT Heini Adams IS better than Ricky January Wink

By USARugbyfan - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
At last no January -but Earl the pearl! man what has he got that gets him selected? There are loads of 15's and 10's better than him and that is the ONLY 2 positions he can play! No WP NEL???
Very glad that Riaan Viljoen was included-he must grab this opportunity to stake his claim for the 15 jersey!!!He is way better than Zane Kirchner!So is Joe Peterson!! And I do believe that Sykes should be rated above Hargrieves??? Anyone agree with me???

By 02kantorowichs - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
No Mapoe
No Deysel

Big surprises for me

By Ali - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
ndungane is a has been and nokwe just doesn't have what it takes. mapoe should have replaced both of these tourists

By jauk - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Earl Rose?Bandise Maku?Meyer Bosman?Odwa Ndugane?Chiliboy Ralepelle?

Maybe I should start playing rugby again, looks like you can become a Springbok just by being a reserve?playing crap?Or being a has-been?

At least they get a all expenses paid trip to europe EEEHAAAAAAA!

By canon1969 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Its Simply a joke that Earl Rose has been selected again.There are a few others that are not of Springbok matarial but we will have to wait and see and worry again.Nothing new in South Africa. Question

By USARugbyfan - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Also guys,PDV has huge pressure on him to fill the quota!!!And this from a country that wont let the Maori team tour because they are selected on race!!!! How stupid can you get? PDV has proven that if left alone,he will select the strongest side possible! Regardless of race!Which is how it should be.A lot of the guys going over wont even get game it seems?How many times can you replace a wing if you have 6 and only need 2 with 1 backup? Surprised Shocked Rolling Eyes Embarassed Mad Crying or Very sad

By student - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Anyone seen francois Hougaard at 12?

By Boesman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
What about Tiaan Liebenberg, WP Nel?
Is Mapoe injured? He was definitely one of the finds of the season. Joe Pieterson as impact player?

Glad Riaan Viljoen is in. What an impressive player.

Why Earl Rose is in the team, I don't know. I haven't seen a more underachieving player. He has all the skills, but doesn't know he has it or doesn't know how to use it.

By smart - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
And here it starts we all knew it is coming, how do some of these guys feel about being chosen when they know there are much better players out there. There are players in this team who know they have never done enough to be a bok. How do true Bok players put up with these guys when there on tour?

By USARugbyfan - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
They should let the Pearl Rose play against the All Blacks-They will not only expose his uselessness but will probably frighten him away from rugby for good-and Kirchner- not a bok at all!Rugby is not something you can walk into-you have to play it from a young age to develop what I call a "rugby brain" the ability to read the game and act accordingly.In 5 to 10 years there will be a lot more black players around that learned the game from small and then can be selected on merit for the Bokke!To push the matter now will only result in a losing team!!So give it time- it will sort itself out without interference!!!

By riek1988 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
earl rose isn`t making the lions team on a regular basis and hes in the team,if ur going to pick a quota player there is more to choose from than old goose step himself

By since1995! - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Deserving players:

heini adams
juan de jongh (if youre a province supporter you would know his talents)
francois hougaard
riaan viljoen
ashley johnson
dewald potgieter
davon raubenheimer


Undeserving players:

Odwa Ndungane
Ruan Pienaar
Earl Rose
Alistair Hargreaves
Bandise Maku
Jannie Du Plessis


Unlucky Players:

Lionel Mapoe
Rory Kockott
Steven Sykes
Adriaan Strauss
Wp Nel

By rugby-man - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
This is a massive dissapointment. Jaque-louis potgeiter should really be here too. We have no decent backup fly half still. Oh except for earl rose. Hes pure class Laughing

By botsbok - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Ok im convinced PDV is obsessed with Earl Rose... It's only an unhealthy obsession that can lead to such decisions...

By Campo - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Hargreaves.. not even a quota, there is no reason for him being there! Meyer Bosman is useless. Not to mention that piece of ....... Early Pearly. Maku? Ralapelle???Nokwe???

Why is Mapoe not there? ?WP Nel? Deysel?Strauss(Ariaan)?? Jaques Lombard??

Did he randomly draw names when he picked the squad??

By Coolc4t - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
b e f o k k e n l a g l i k ! ! !

By Coolc4t - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Alistair Hargreaves Ashley Johnson Bandise Maku Heinke van der Merwe Heini Adams Meyer Bosman Francois Hougaard Zane Kirchner Earl Rose Riaan Viljoen ???????????????????????????????????????

so u say...

15 riaan viljoen
14 francois hougaard
13 adi jackobs
12 meyer bosman
11 zane kirchner
10 earl rose
9 heini adams
8 ashley johnston
7 dewald potgieter
6 duvon raubenheimer
5 alister harkreeves
4 andries bekker
3 guthro steenkamp
2 bandise maku
1 heiko vd merve

will beat

15 joe pietersen
14 lionel mapoe
13 juan de jong (fine he made team)/wylon murry
12 pieter grant/riaan swannepoel
11 geo aplon
10 naas olivier/pieter grant
9 sarel pretorius/jano vermaak
8 willem alberts/luke twatsen
7 juan smith/juan dysel
6 francois louw/j botes
5 anton van zyl/ f vd merve
4 s sykes
3 wp nel
2 tiaan liebenberg/derick kuun/andries straus
1 wikus blaauw

u tell me...cause i is no understand???

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
well chilliboys captianing the mid week team
Im fed up of this affrimative action cr@p

By StefanA - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Affirmative (bl)action - How can Earl Rose,Bandise Maku,Peppersteak Ralepele and Heini Adams be in the side instead of Joe Pieterson,Tiaan Liebenberg,Adriaan Strauss and Sarel Pretorius.It is an absolute DISGRACE. SA rugby team now just as useless as SA Parliament. Hope they lose every game.

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
well the anc has finally gotcomplete control of SA rugby
only 10 years after the 99 team were told there would never be an all white springbok side again before they played and recorded our only loss against wales
Have to say I bought my last bok jersey last year this team isnt the same one I aspired to play for when I was younger

By BullsRob - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls!!!!!!!!!

Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile Smile

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
have to say Ive no quams with Heini Adams being in there hes been constantly performing well over the past few years

By Sharkling - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Well I guess you can please some of the people some of the time, but not all of the people all of the time... if we come back as losers, then you lot can all chirp. But until then keep your opinions above the belt...

By Jack - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I stand by my theory...there's no doubt whatsoever that Earl Rose is PDV's illegitimate child, there's just no two ways about it!!! Laughing

Either that, or PDV is pitching for the other team, if you get what I'm saying?! Shocked

I just can't believe that Joe Pietersen isn't in there, he really had a good season, but I think everyone knows why...because PDV is mad about Pearls.

By Jack - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
The reason being related to Joe Pietersen not being selected that is, not in relation to him having a good season, sorry.

By mat369 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Race shouldnt be a problem. Rugby is built on talent, but when players such as Earl Rose joins the team, they just chase away the other players who actually has got some talent. When we start losing again, and all our great players have gone overseas because they could never play in green and gold because of their skin colour, what are they going to do then? We are the best in the world, and they want to put that on the line because there is not enough talented black players.. Sad, very sad...

By swing-it-wide - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
I just wana pont out to a couple of people that this is a rugby forum, not a place to vent out your race issues!!! I see so mant people complaining about Maku; chiliboy; raubenheimer; rose; adams, buy only 2 people complain about hargreaves!!! Do not be hippocrates - chirp him too!!! He is probably the least deserving out of all of them. And heinke van der Merwe??? When was the last game he played? He was quite average this year's super 14 and has played no rugby since then!! Wikus Blauuw and DuPreez are much better options! Don't get me wrong, i would also like to see Liebenberg and Strauss instead of maku and chili; Deysel or vermeulen instead of raubenheimer; Potgieter instead of adams; Mapoe before any of those wingers (except habana and JP); and anyone ahead of rose!! My point - chuck the racial issues and criticise everyone fairly!!!

By The_Lion - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Mapoe = find of the season. But what the selectors were smoking when they picked Rose, Maku, Hargrieves and Sweet-Chilli i don't know.

By junior_bok10 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
before i rant about the obvious political decisions, i have to say that we still have a 22 there to beat any team in the world and this is why PDV is lucky.....i believe he is a good coach but it is the quality of players that have kept us at the top!!

ok right there are 15 players of colour in that squad!!!!!!.....i have decided that 7 of them deserve to be there(on form!!):
habana
JP
adams
beast
johnson
kirchner
nokwe....just(rather mapoe)

pdv vowed a couple of weeks ago to select these guys on merit.....he actually had my hopes up until i saw these names in the squad:

maku???????....he hasn't started many currie cup game this season!!-wouldn't make the leicester midweek side

chilliboy(actually not that bad but not no.2 in the country)

raubenheimer-ahead of vermeulen, alberts, viljoen,deysel,louw....i don't think so!

steenkamp-wp nel is a country mile better and wicus blaauw

jacobs-can't defend, where is riaan swanepoel or even barry geel???

earl rose-nuff said.......useless

odwa ndungane...average, not intl standard!!

we have much better depth than this and the choices are racist against white players who deserve to be there on merit and form!

agreed hargreaves doesn't deserve to be there, well what about van zyl and sykes????

By junior_bok10 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
these will be our two teams, which actually don't look too bad on paper Very Happy :
test XV

beast
bismarck
john
victor
bakkies
brussow
schalk
spies
fdp
morne steyn
bryan habana
wyand olivier
jaque fourie
jp pietersen
riaan viljoen

midweek XV
riaan viljoen
francois houghaard
juan de jongh
meyer bosman
odwa ndungane
ruan pienaar
heini adams
ashley johnson
ryan kankowski
danie roussow
alistair hargreaves
andries bekker
jannie du Plessis
chilliboy
gurthro steenkamp

By forgottenplayer - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I watched the extra time of the U21 final yesterday and was really glad to see many players of different colors playing. Therefore is no need to push anything, they will come trough the system. But I do not wonder if Adrian Strauss, Joe Pietersen, WP Nel, Steven Sykes, Duane Vermeulen, Anton van Zyl, Willem Steenkamp, Gerhart van den Heever or other players are going to sign overseas contracts soon and in the some worst cases are going to play for England, France or even Italy in a few vears.

By forgottenplayer - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
... in some worst cases...

By sasuperman20 - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
It's always the same old sob story on this website - a squad of 37 players picked, first everyone was crying about Rose but how did that turn out - nothing happened. Let's play like adults here and stop crying like school girls (no offence ladies Cool )

By BaDGer1 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Ok seriously. Heini Adams instead of Sarel Pretorius/Rory Kockott? SHOCKING.

By Divan - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
We couldve take 2 teams over there either of which who would've given France, Italy and Ireland a pakslae! Now we have a "B team" that we have to be nervous of loosing to Sarascens!

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
People go on about the race of the squads because they arent picked on merit at all
Joe pieterson should be there, so should peter grant
earl the pearl about as useful as a c@*k flavoured lolly pop
Even Nass deserves a shot he had a great season with griquas
Agree with junior with the 7 on meritt
think well get beasted by the tigers in the first mid-week game
Mean if the anc are desprate enough to have a black bok captian cant we just make chilliboy it full time see how cr@p he is and have the farse over and done with

By Sharkbok - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Joe Pieterson instead of Earl Grey Rose.
Joe Pieterson can also kick, unlike Ruan Pienaar.

Rose will play for the last minute of each game, and maybe get a test cap doing this as well.

It is a short tour- 3 tests, and 2 midweek games.
So it will be the usual test 23 doing the business.

Heini Adams is a quality player- perhaps not the 2nd best but no qualms with him playing.
However he is currently in much better than Januarie "get out jail free card".

By junior_bok10 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
legend killer chilliboy is confirmed as the midweek captain Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy ........what a joke!!!!!!!!

can't see guys like kanko and bekker listening to him, or any of the team actually for that matter Very Happy

imagine what derick kuun is thinking!.....he has kept these guys on the bench at loftus for 2 years!!

legend killer ur also right about pietersen though viljoen is a better addition imo!

peter grant should definitely be there ahead of rose and J L Potgieter should have been a definite because he is the best attacking 10 in the country!

By Sharkbok - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Earl Grey 5 Roses is like a weak cup of tea.

By mrlammy - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
alberts and deysel should feel unlucky but back row is very strong for SA.
WP Nel and Mapoe are very unlucky as they played so well yesterday and this season. Not too awful i think

By BullsRob - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I feel sorry for Earl Rose. You haters are miss-directing your anger. He isn't good enough, agreed, but he doesn't select himself. Blame the selectors not the player!!!

By Freikorp - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I DO NOT SEE THE NAME OF JEAN DEYSEL ANYWHERE!!! WHY ARE THE BOKS GOIGN TO KEEP ON USING THE SAME PLAYERS, BECAUSE THERE NO VISION. IF PDV WAS SMART HE WOULD START BUILDING TOWARDS 2011 WITH NEW BLOOD. JEAN DEYSEL, BRUSSOUW AND VERMUELEN THATS WHO I WANNNA SEE NOW!!!! OUT WITH THE OLD IN WITH THE NEW

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Well if rose isnt good enough and by now no doubt knows that why doesnt he do the respectable thing and withdraw himself from the squad
Yeah Junior I knew he was the captian 2 days ago it said on planet rugby, cant believe it. Well least there are no colours awarded for the mid week games
Id even rather see watson in the squad over chilliboy whos nickname must be sore butt from pulling all the splinters out of his @ss from sitting on the bence
Cant believe there arent more western province guys after their run and the cheeths have a front row for the future
Have to admit I think Juan smith is past it but we have no recognised attacking inside centre which grant could be

By Jack - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Oh, how the plot has thickened! We all heard the rumors that Chilliboy was being groomed as the next Springbok captain, and to be fair I think he did an awesome job for the U/19 & U/21 teams when he played (and captained both or at least the U/19 as I remember), BUT he hasn't featured anywhere since then. He's been totally outplayed & outclassed by Derick Kuun over the last couple of seasons and next year he'll be lucky to even get a spot on the bench with Gary Botha heading back to Loftus.

I get the whole transformation thing, but it seems that our Government, and yes this is the workings of our government, just can't seem to grasp the correct application of BEE or Transformation! It is supposed to give everyone a fair chance and yes help previously disadvantaged people, but what they don't seem to get is that those people are still supposed to be qualified for that position. You can't sacrifice efficiency or quality of performance by introducing sub-standard players/employees.

If anyone was wondering why there still exists racial tensions in SA Rugby, it is a result of the wrongful application of transformation. These tools, just like our clueless politicians, are actually defeating their own purpose by promoting stereotypes about black/colored players & keeping this notion of quota players alive. Mad

And then there's Maku...W.T.F?! Shocked

By Jack - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
===> Correction <===

I actually didn't mean BEE, but AA (Affirmative Action).

My bad! Rolling Eyes

By Luway - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Swing-it-Wide, I can't agree with you more.

It's amazing how ppl are quick to jump on the quota selections (which I agree, many of them are unfortunately) but yet miss the biggest joke of them all (except Rose of course), Hargreaves. And Bosman must consider himself very lucky.

I can only assume Mapoe is injured... Otherw his non-selection is shocking. Deysel would've been awesome in the northern hemisphere and WP Nel must be the most unfortunate player to miss out.

Nevertheless, in PDV I trust. Go Bokke!

By junior_bok10 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
luway we only do this because we don't politics to mix with sport like it has in this selection and surely every bok supporter wants to see the best players on the field nevermind the colour of their skin!!!!!!!!

By Willeklong - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
The players picked aren't actually that crap (bar Earl Roes, he's shaait!). Maku? Not too sure what thats all about. Strauss and Liebenberg is better than both him and Chilliboy. Liebenberg is getting a bit long in the tooth so he's probably not a solid investment for the future, but Strauss def is.

Haven't seen Davon Raubenheimer much, can't picture that even the most passionate Griqua fan can admit that he is better tha Francois Louw. Francois Louw deserved to be included, the boy is SOLID, ask the Bulls. Then there is still Jean Deysel, Vermeulen, Steggman, Alberts (not all ball cariers, but still!)

Stoked for De Jongh, hope he gets decent game time. That kid will make a BIG impact, mark my words.

Joe Pietersen above Rose as impact player/ versatile back any day!

Heini Adams is solid enough, he won't disappoint.

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
well its that way with other countired the best players are on the pitch you dont see them having a quota in the all blacks for maoris do you as they werent treated equally when it was a coloney

By junior_bok10 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
legendkiller:

as far as i'm aware we are the only sporting nation that has this terrible clash of politics and rugby......sad!

By sasuperman20 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
junior and legend really should get a room...
reason sport and politics clash is because of our history: now pump the breaks, i know what you're thinking "it's in the past, get over it!" thing is, it's easy for us to say that because we're white (I say we, because I'm in the same boat) but instead of crying about it - we move forward. There are LOADS of players that are unlucky, we all know that, and it hurts just as much for everyone else watching. But the bigger picture is that SOuth Africa IS producing great players, and as things go forward they will change - one has to hope

By bootman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I agree sasuperman. I feel really agrieved that aplon, mapoe,and even francious louw didnt make it but Im not going to cry about it on this forum. People are saying dont mix politics and sport but they come on a public forum and use words like quota, affirmative action and say things like "he was chosen because of the colour of his skin" I think this in itself is mixing politics and sport.

I personally dont think guys like Rose deserves to be there but does that automatically make him a quota selection? If thats the case what do you call a white player who doesnt(according to us) deserve his place?

Meyer Bosman is certainly not even the fourth best centre in SA but lets see what PDV and the guys have in stall for him. Im definately not going critisize until I know whats cooking.

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
never said we werent grooming great players but the good players of other races and colour never get selected just the pawns
as I said Ive no problem with adams, de jongh and such just lose the dead weight like chilliboy
Love to see that people assume that Im white?? for all you know I could be black
Bosman is there mainly as hes a utility player and right now the inform inside centre would be grant but where is he??
We have no replacement as of yet for jdv
As you say yeah it is the past but do you see america who have the same past making quotas and racially picked players for there teams in any sport no! Everyones there on merit
the governmant wants to develope underprivaledged communities then go to the townships and develop centres and pitches
You so called new south africans would sell your souls to look good to people. Junior and me just say what everyone else is thinking and too afraid to say. People have to be there own person and not afriad to say what they feel and think, not worry who will stab you in the back for doing it
Bad enough they B@sterdised the jersy in moving the bok in the first place but where were you all in standing up in protests and that, no were all to scared of the big bad ANC

By junior_bok10 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
bootman as i've said before i am just a proud bok supporter who waqnts to see the best players in the country on the pitch......when i see players who shouldn't be there i am naturally angry and so should you be!!!.....at the moment it is just a coincidence that the lucky call-ups are players of colour cos i genuinely think meyer bosman is a decent player and hargreaves has got potential!!!

and i am bringing up the politics in sport issue because i believe the past has gone now yet it still raises it's ugly head in sport!!!

why do we have 20-30 sa-born players in europe????......maybe because of lifestyle and money but surely there is truth in them leaving because they believe they won't get a chance in a politically corrupt rugby country!!!

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 1
Well said Junior end of the day we want the best team on the pitch not one where plays have to carry others because of politics

By omacburma - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
i usually am sick of the quota crying, but this squad is shocking. and most of the time pvd has picked on merit this year..

however, to be fair alot of the picks are bad regardless of race. the two hvdm instead of the cheetahs front row? alistar whats his name instead of sykes? bekker hasn't been good all season.

oh well, i still will support you boks, but really, get your act together, white people are south africans too.

By lalapanz - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
This kind of racist crap is one of the reasons I left SA. Leave the f....ing politics out of all sport and play the best players. Racists

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
lalapanz its a good thing you left cause we don't need panzeys like you here. Go find a web site from your new country you pathetic bickering idiot.

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
BIG shockers are- MAKU?? Potgieter?? Adams?? Raubenheimer?? Jonki?? Earl?? Viljoen??

Usual shockers- Jacobs? Odwa? Chillieman? Steenkamp?

Should have been there- Vermneulen, Deysel, Andries Strauss/Tiaan Liebenberg/ Kuun(even Burden for heavens sake!), Jano Vermaak, Mapoe, Peter Grant and Joe Pieterson.

New faces im very happy to see-

Allistar Hargreaves-(Big tall chap, young so he can learn from the best two examples in the world)

Hougard- This boy is the definition of talent and determination

Heinke- We all know what he can do.

De Jong- Brilliant talent, speed and willingness.

Bosman- What a trooper.

Kirchner- Lets hope he regains the magic form from earlier this year.


Thats all!
Very Happy Very Happy

By darooosta - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Earl Rose?

Bandise Maku ?

Chilliboy Ralephelle ?

Davon Raubenheimer ?

What what what?!!! Do the selectors have an issue against province? They had a great season and deserved to be in the final!! Where are Liebenberg, Grant, Pietersen, Aplon, Louw???

By ldamon - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Earl you the man. He's got all the skills .PDV will nuture him and get the best out of him.He is earmarked to wear our No.15 jersey so all of you get over yourselves.

By crazysharksman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA Idamon... LOL good one Very Happy

By f.barnard - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I THINK MAPOE SIGNED A SEVENS CONTRACT THATS WHY HE'S NOT THERE

By ldamon - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
You all can call this qouta selections if you want ,so what , these guys all got big potensial. They must just grab this oppertunity. Chiliboy is a great player and got leadership potensial -PDV know this guy from junior level and know what his got in this boytjie. I honestly think the selections for this end of year tour is great and the new guys must just step out onto the plate. Let's give our boys a chance nad see what they worth. Go PDV go Bokke go.

By greenmachine - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Why did they leave Mapoe behind? He is brilliant, he is the right colour and even Gio Aplon, a bit small but he is a fantastic player and he fits the transformation bill. It just doesn't make sense to me.

By ldamon - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
They not looking at colour ,you are Greenmachine. I also think they good player but unfortunately they have not been chosen because the selector thought otherwise.They cannot please each and everyone.

By sasuperman20 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Legend, I can't believe how you are comparing our racial history to that of America's...really? We've only been democratic for the past 16 years where they have been Independant since 1776 and in a country (SA) where the minority (whites,) are ruling over the majority- it's the complete opposite to the US, so please, know the facts before throwing out statements like that. I'm over the race thing now, the 20-30 players playing abroad didn't win us the world cup, the vast majority were on home grown soil. As much as I don't like Olivier, I feel he is the in form centre and he will do well on the tour.
Rose shouldn't be there, but in a country like SA - do you think that WE would have chosen a guy like O'connors. Point, the guy makes things happen on the field, not always the right things - but he can win games - i don't mind him coming off the bench in the midweek games

By StefanA - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Idamon -If you think this team is not based on quotas then you are obviously mentally challenged. And if you think Earl Rose is the man,then you are obviously the idiot.

By ldamon - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Stefana - I've never said thay not looking at Qoutas ,it will be and must be part of all selections in sport in SA. It will take years for us to correct all the wrongs the people of this country had to endure. PDV and his boks will make SA proud so all the best to him and his troops.

By TheRealSlimGary - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Earl Rose.......come now, PvD must be getting some side action from this guy. Maybe Earl sold PvD some performance drugs before his sex take

By TheRealSlimGary - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
In my opinion, all the players of color deserve to be in the team (expect earl-f*cken-rose). I'd even go so far as to say that they shouldve included Lionel Mapoe - another coloured player

By greenmachine - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Here is a fact, there are players of colour that ARE good enough to be in the side, that have been left behind, and there are white players that have been included in the squad that shouldn't be there. I am all for transformation and in Gio Aplon, Mapoe, Nokwe it is easy to see why, but I just think the selectors are mad. I mean Rose, Chilliboy (Who has played about 12 minutes of rugby this year), Adi Jacobs, Meyer Bosman????? Come one, what are these guys smoking?

By Gron - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Ok. The only 2 players I have a big issue with is Rose and Chilli. Chilli only because of his lack of game-time. He'll be injured in the first game and will be back in SA by this weekend.

Rose? No brainer. If they tell me they've been working on him full time for the last few months, I'd give him a chance, but I seriously doubt it.

Mapoe SHOULD have been there. 7s contracts can be overwritten for Bok-duty.

By Rqd2 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
I wish this talk of quotas would stop, if a player is good enough, he is good enough, there will always be disagreements on selection, at the end of the day, the coach and selectors will live and die by their choices, it's their head on the block... Fortunately in SA we have a dirth of depth and talent at the moment, and i think we can finally say that the hangover of isolation has passed, the boks are back where they should be, on top with their great foes The All Blacks...

As for Earl Rose, well, somebody needs to carry the bags and water bottles...

By StefanA - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Rqd2 - We will stop talking about quotas when they stop picking according to quotas. I'm not a racist. I would like to see Earl Rose dropped because he is useless,not because he's coloured. I will gladly support a team consisting of 22 black players,as long as they are the 22 best players in the country.

By barter - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
WP Nel is the big loser here!

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
end of the day quotas is very much alive you mean to tell me chilliboy is better than strauss?? Or that earl is better than grant??
come on earl is dead weight he cant break into any squads and he showed against the lions how useless he is
Think youll find super that racial persacution(spelt wrong I know) was far worse in the states with the clan and that
end of the story is theres no quotas or breaks for them there, they get in on hard work and merrit
Argeed that this isnt the best squad and if we keep this up well end up like we were in 2003
right now yes we have the best starting XV in the world but those guys arent going to be around forever
Now would have been a prome time for barrit but hes now in the saxons and could be a player to haunt us in the future
As for calling people whiners no people are standing up for what they believe in that a team should be picked regardless of colour, the only colour they should be is green!!!!!!!!!
Ideal team
15 J Fietersen
14 JP Piertsen
13 J Fourie
12 Peter Grant
11 B Habana
10 M Steyn
9 f du Preez
8 P Spies
7 S Burger
6 H Brussow
5 V Matfield
4 B Botha
3 J Smit
2 B du Plessis
1 T Mtawarira

bench
16 A Bekker
17 R Pienaar
18 WP Nel
19 W Blaauw
20 J de Jongh
21 F Hougaard
22 T Liebenberg
23 N Olivier

By sasuperman20 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Have to agree with Barter, WP should have been there. The rest of these comments are just rubbish

By bootman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Can anybody tell me exactly what the quota is???? If there should be 10 black players in the matchday 22 for example then obviously there should be 12 white players right??? Then those 12 white players are quotas too because they are there to make up the numbers.

And legendkiller if you could take the time to tell us you spelled persecution incorrectly, why couldnt you take the time to correct it???

By Rqd2 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Who is J Fieterson?

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
its pieterson just the i's to close the p
and because I was in a hurry at work and didnt have the time to grab a dictionary

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
quota means out of the whole squad a certain percentage has to be of the previously underprivalaged communities
it used to be 2 coloured players had to be on the pitch at all times and so many on the bench

By bootman - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Legendkiller my friend.....I know what quota means. I just want to know what the numbers are supposed to be. Everybody is on about quotas but nobody really knows how many "players of colour" according to the so called quota system are supposed to be in the squad.

By since1995! - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
when the country first saw and heard 'bryan habana' , they were probably like who?
and over 2 years of development (which none of us foresaw) he became the deadliest, fastest wing, in the world.
When we first saw 'jp pieterson' it was the same, and he was in the world cup winning 15.. (neverminding his miracle, match-saving tackle against fiji..)
-these two are now internationally recognised names now (along with many many other development players from the last 15 years)..

BUT, there was a time when they were nobodies, and when the only people that believed in them were the coaches, who had seen enough to believe in them.

Guys, try keep an open mind-towards new names like Heini Adams, Raubenheimer, Johnson, De jongh.. Transformation has worked in the past, and definitely has helped win us world cups and tri-nations ...

that said, Rose, Ndungane, and others, who have been given enough chances, should be gone soon .. ( along with ruan pienaar ..)

By legendkiller - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
its the last lot of names Im talking about aswell as chilliboy, they shouldnt be there

By sasuperman20 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Is this forum on replay because it's the same things again and again and again...lets see how these lads play before we get
down their throats, the first game is going to be crucial for the dirt trackers

By impi - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
in my view there are waaaay to many good players in south africa at the moment to be relying on the wrong people.

these players are just not good enough
chilliboy and bandise maku are tokens they arent even bulls first choice...so if derrick kuun is first choice for bulls and clearly outplays both of them how can he not be selected if they are
adrian jacobs... good year last year useless since he is carrying his injury
francois hougaard... good but i would rather have seen either mapoe or juries those okes deserve a chance
hieni adams...better than januarie but i am pretty sure its a waste... ruan should be the back up scrummy. he is ten times the player.
earl rose????? i dont even need to comment!

basically we still seeing token players... how can we unite as a country when select people are still given express passes to the front of the queu when there are more deserving hard working players who have to watch from the sidelines... wondering... what if?? i understand many are there being given chances in the midweek games but currie cup and super 14 provide chances for players to prove themselves. the springbok squad is for playrs that have already proven themselves... end of!

By impi - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
added to that what about kockott>? he is amazing! and i'm a bulls fan so its not like i am only singing praises to my team! a differetn way would be for ruan to cover flyhalf while rory covers scrummy! wont be surprised if rory leaves to play in mud island for the poms! cos face it he will never get his chance

By sasuperman20 - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
Partly agree with Impi with your selections, Juries is a bit too old though if you want to blood new peeps. Kockett for me is just too much of a loose cannon, same as a guy like Kuun, very good players but loose the plot too often. We have plenty of Scrummies, Sarel P is a good player but after one season he still has time, a guy like Vermaak is outstanding too

By Ruboy - Castle Braai recommendations: 0
No doubt there's a couple of players that dont belong in this squad and I'm sure there's room for development with these guys, but how can you put underdeveloped players into a NATIONAL side. Question

No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register or login.
Login / Register
 
user poll
Who will be SA's top side in the 2010 S14?





Results Votes: 23192
Store

2008 Springbok Jersey with Name and Number

2008 Springbok Jersey with Name and Number
2008 Bok Jersey with Name and Number.

PLEASE NOTE: This jersey is available on pre-order. It has not yet been released.

Fat Pig Productions
Designed and Implemented by DigIT Solutions All content supplied by SARugby.com Photographs supplied by Gallo Images/Getty Images. All logos and trademarks are the property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all the rest © 2005 Fat Pig Productions CC
The logos and trademarks used on this site are the property of their respective owners
We are not responsible for comments posted by our users, as they are the property of the poster
Advertise with SARugby.com | Legal Notices

SARugby.com is hosted by Hetzner